Execution Is The Strategy

Subscribe – Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube

HR’s Credibility Crisis: From Ideas to Impact

HR functions struggle to gain strategic influence despite touching every aspect of the employee lifecycle. In this episode, co-hosts Jackson Lynch and Scott Morris dissect why HR faces a persistent credibility gap in organizations. They argue that HR’s focus on programs rather than business results, combined with slow execution timelines, undermines their strategic value. The hosts explore how HR can reclaim credibility by adopting methodologies from lean manufacturing and product development, emphasizing that true strategy isn’t about grand ideas but about selecting the right tactical interventions to drive specific business outcomes. They stress that operational excellence enables agility rather than stifling it, and that HR must separate compliance-driven perfection from areas where iterative, experimental approaches deliver better results.

Three Key Takeaways

• HR talks programs, not business results – The credibility gap exists because HR focuses on describing their initiatives rather than the business outcomes those programs achieve. Leaders want to hear about revenue impact, not training curricula or development processes.
• Strategy is tactical selection, not big ideas – True strategic HR means looking at business problems through a talent lens, identifying root causes, and selecting the right intervention from your toolkit. The strategic moment is narrow—picking which of five possible tactics will have the best impact right now.
• Operational excellence enables agility, not hinders it – HR can be both rigorous and fast by separating compliance-driven perfection from areas where experimentation is valuable. The goal is turning 9-month processes into 9-day processes while maintaining measurement and feedback loops.

Practical Advice

The Four-Step Credibility Recovery Framework:

1. Audit Your Execution Capability – Examine where breakdowns happen: unclear ownership, poor adoption tracking, weak feedback loops. This audit becomes your priority work because executional excellence drives credibility.
2. Build Execution Playbooks – Treat every HR initiative like a business rollout with sequencing, role clarity, contingency planning, and stakeholder management. Use proven models like Kotter’s change management framework.
3. Establish PMO Support – Invest in formal execution support through a project management office or dedicated execution specialist. Don’t leave complex implementations to untrained managers or junior teams.
4. Train in Operational Excellence – Develop HRBPs and line leaders in change management, agile methodologies, and process design. These delivery disciplines must be elevated across the function.

Remember: Apply the “so that” mentality religiously. Every HR project should complete this sentence: “I am working on [initiative] so that [specific business outcome].” Measure HR work by business results, not program completion.

Want More?

1. Influencer: The New Science of Leading Change by Kerry Patterson – A comprehensive guide to creating behavioral change by identifying vital behaviors and using six sources of influence to drive lasting organizational transformation
2. Why Most Change Programs Fail – Analysis of common pitfalls in organizational change initiatives and how leaders can improve success rates through better planning and execution discipline (Harvard Business Review, May 2023)
3. The Agile HR Operating Model – McKinsey insights on how HR functions can adopt agile methodologies to increase speed, responsiveness, and business impact while maintaining operational rigor (McKinsey & Company, February 2024)

Skip to Footer

Founder & CEO

Copy link