Before You Take That CHRO Job…

Subscribe – Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube

Why Context Matters More Than Capability

Most CHRO job interviews focus on the wrong questions. In this episode, co-hosts Jackson Lynch and Scott Morris dive deep into a real-world scenario where Jackson was offered and then declined a CHRO position within 48 hours. Scott and Jackson explore why operational leaders undervalue HR and how HR professionals condition this behavior through reactive problem-solving rather than proactive business strategy. Through Jackson’s personal story of navigating a bankruptcy and potential new role, they reveal the critical importance of assessing business context before accepting any senior HR position. The discussion centers on the harsh reality that talented CHROs cannot single-handedly transform organizations that aren’t ready for strategic human capital work, and why walking away from mismatched opportunities protects both personal reputation and business outcomes.

Three Key Takeaways

• HR leaders condition operational leaders to undervalue them – When HR focuses on compliance, administration, and reactive problem-solving instead of business outcomes like revenue per employee or talent concentration risk, they train executives to see HR as a cost center rather than a strategic driver.
• Context trumps capability every time – Even exceptional CHROs cannot transform organizations that aren’t ready for progressive HR work. Success requires either joining companies already doing strategic human capital work or working with CEOs who have seen it before and are committed to driving alignment across the C-suite.
• Revenue per employee and talent density are the metrics that matter – Instead of measuring engagement survey completion rates or performance management process participation, strategic HR focuses on business outcomes like concentration risk (when 80% of revenue comes from 20% of people) and talent allocation as portfolio management.

Practical Advice

The CHRO Context Assessment Framework:

Before accepting any senior HR role, evaluate these critical factors:

1. Reporting Structure – If the CHRO reports to the CFO instead of the CEO, walk away. You cannot drive business performance through human capital from that position.
2. Business Understanding – Develop a clear plan for how human capital drives business performance. Know how the business makes money, loses money, and what the key levers are before you can contribute strategically.
3. CEO Partnership Assessment – Ask about the last 10 discussions the CEO had with their current CHRO. This reveals whether they view HR as strategic or administrative.

The Three Types of CEOs:

• Champions: Absolutely get strategic HR and will partner with you
• Skeptics: Don’t get it and want HR in a compliance box
• Learners: Want to understand how human capital can drive business results and are open to leadership

Key Interview Questions to Ask:

• “Tell me about the last 10 discussions you had with your current CHRO”
• “How do you measure business performance, and where do you see human capital fitting in?”
• “What’s your experience with HR as a strategic business driver versus administrative function?”

Remember: You cannot be the person who opens everyone’s eyes to strategic HR. Join organizations ready for that work or find yourself perpetually frustrated trying to push water uphill.

Want More?

1. Talent Wins: The New Playbook for Putting People First by Ram Charan, Dominic Barton, and Dennis Carey – Essential guide for elevating the CHRO role from administrative function to strategic business partner focused on revenue, margin, and market share outcomes
2. People Before Strategy: A New Role for the CHRO – Harvard Business Review analysis of why most CEOs undervalue their HR function and how to redefine the CHRO role around predicting, diagnosing, and prescribing talent solutions that create value (Harvard Business Review, July 2015)
3. Reimagining HR: Insights from People Leaders – McKinsey research with 80+ CHROs showing how successful HR leaders transform from support functions to strategic partners by focusing on agility, business impact, and organizational transformation (McKinsey & Company, March 2022)

Skip to Footer

Founder & CEO

Copy link